Insights
Failing rental property market needs an urgent supply boost
By Simon French, Chief Economist and Head of Research
It is one of the peculiarities of UK economic commentary that so much attention is paid to homeowners. Following a change in interest rates the default approach of the media is to consider the impact on those with a mortgage. Any debate over Inheritance Tax has inevitably been conducted through the lens of the family home. This focus on those who own their own property squeezes out thirty-five percent of Britons for whom this framing is largely irrelevant - those that rent their homes. The rental sector has been the poor relation in a UK economy where property wealth – despite its 16% fall in real terms since 2022 – retains a huge psychological resonance.
An eye-watering 49% of UK wealth - almost £7 trillion - is tied up in the value of UK residential property. That is almost double the quarter share of US household wealth, where ownership of financial assets is the dominant feature. The scale of exposure to property wealth in the UK means that falling UK property prices - and the impact this has on consumer sentiment and spending power - is the prevailing economic narrative. It is also a narrative that ignores the third of the population for whom those issues are of little direct concern.
So this column will try to redress the balance. In doing so it considers the financial outlook for nearly nine million British households living in the private and social rented sectors. There is little doubt that this government considers the fortunes of renters as a political priority. But this on its own will not generate better outcomes. Indeed, replacing market failure with government failure is an ever-present risk around all public policy interventions. The rules governing the rented sector are no different. The rental market has been a keen focus of the legislative agenda with the recent Renters Reform Act, moves to change leasehold and ground rent conditions, as well as new requirements on landlords to investigate and fix housing hazards. The question for most tenants is what impacts such efforts to intervene will have on rents.
The early data is not particularly encouraging. Last week’s data from the Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) saw surveyor expectations for rents rise to their highest level since early 2024. This is against the backdrop of English rents already rising faster than the rate of pay growth. Rent inflation in England is currently running at 4.0% a year according to the ONS.
It is instructive that comparable rents in Scotland – where the market is not bound by the recent Renters Reform Act by dint of devolution – are rising at just 0.7% a year. The divergence of housing and rental policy between Scotland and England means that when asymmetric policy impacting renters gets enacted it provides helpful data on how these respective markets react.
Since the UK government took office in 2024, average rents have risen by 11.9% in England and just 5.6% in Scotland. Between 2022 and 2024 when Scotland introduced a form of rental control, rents rose 15.6% north of the border. Just 12.8% to the south. These are data that suggest that interventions in the rental market are having, in aggregate, the perverse impact to those that policymakers intended.
So what is driving this?
There has been for some time a concerted effort to transfer costs onto landlords in an expectation that these will be absorbed into margins. From diminished mortgage interest relief, to a higher rental income tax surcharge – these on-costs have risen at the same time as the cost of buy-to-let mortgages have increased in line with a global increase in interest rates. Maintenance costs have also risen sharply in line with inflation in building products and labour.
When faced by increasing operating costs in any market it is the level of competition within that market that determines how much suppliers can pass on. It is no different with landlords. This competitive environment has been shrinking in recent years with Savills estimating that a net 240,000 rental properties have left the U.K. market over the last four years. This leaves remaining landlords with more pricing power as supply shrinks. This constrained supply picture is one of the main reasons why the same Savills report expects rents to outpace incomes across the U.K. over the next five years.
Now it could be that this contraction in supply of rental accommodation is part of a concerted government effort to rotate tenure away from renting, and towards home ownership. As someone with a strong desire to see the UK have more of a stakeholder culture across the U.K. economy, I can see the attractions of this. But if this is the intent, it risks running into two big issues.
Firstly, the housing stock released by landlords has to be affordable for renters seeking to become first time buyers. With the government’s new “Your First Home” policy only available for new build then the barriers for renters to absorb disposed landlord stock are formidable. Secondly, a pivot to greater homeownership is not without risks to the wider economy. A healthy rental sector – particularly at a time when Stamp Duty and Inheritance Tax concerns are an impediment to a vibrant rotation in home ownership – is key for a dynamic and flexible labour market. Bank of England deputy governor, Clare Lombardelli, last week noted the current low level of churn in the UK labour market. Part of the diagnosis of a “low gear” labour market is the friction that a poorly functioning rental market, alongside barriers to housing transactions, pose for labour mobility. Workers seeking a new, higher paid role, even with enhanced remote working, require a rental market that is broad-based and flexible.
The solution for renters, like much that holds back the UK economy, is promoting abundant supply. Not chasing it away. One of the reasons landlords have been able to rent out substandard properties in recent years is because they can. Prospective tenants with limited choice will be forced to take what they can find. Landlords would be forced to raise their game in a market where there is a risk their property doesn’t get rented at all. With Build To Rent starts down 70% this year on viability concerns, those supply and competition dynamics – so key for a healthy market, and lower rents - is getting worse.
I suspect that as overall inflation rises next year the government will question why, amidst all its interventions, renters will again feel the pain. More rental competition, not less, remains the answer.